
Though I’ve been a prog rock guy as far back as memory allows, I’m always open to fine, angular, and clever pop. When pop is done well, count me in as a huge fan. If I begin to list favorite prog albums—say a favorite 50 or 100 list—my mind starts to get a bit foggy, and my opinion changes, day by day, and, for better or worse, hour by hour. Not necessarily the top 10, but everything else begins to swirl and maneuver, position by position, place by place.
When it comes to my favorite pop (broadly defined, I suppose) albums, though, I can readily list them and, amazingly enough, in chronological order. I assume this is because my mind isn’t as full of pop as it is prog.
So, for better or worse, here goes.
- Beach Boys, PET SOUNDS
- Thomas Dolby, GOLDEN AGE OF WIRELESS
- ABC, LEXICON OF LOVE
- Simple Minds, NEW GOLD DREAM
- Roxy Music, AVALON
- ABC, BEAUTY STAB
- Blancmange, HAPPY FAMILIES
- Psychedelic Furs, FOREVER NOW
- Echo and the Bunnymen, PORCUPINE
- Echo and the Bunnymen, OCEAN RAIN
- Simple Minds, SPARKLE IN THE RAIN
- Talk Talk, IT’S MY LIFE
- Big County, STEELTOWN
- Alphaville, FOREVER YOUNG
- Psychedelic Furs, MIRROR MOVES
- New Order, LOW LIFE
- Bryan Ferry, BOYS AND GIRLS
- Cure, HEAD ON THE DOOR
- Kate Bush, HOUNDS OF LOVE
- The Smiths, MEAT IS MURDER
- Tears for Fears, SONGS FROM THE BIG CHAIR
- The Smiths, QUEEN IS DEAD
- XTC, SKYLARKING
- Bryan Ferry, BETE NOIRE
- Sundays, READING, WRITING, AND ARITHMATIC
- World Party, GOODBYE JUMBO
- Matthew Sweet, GIRLFRIEND
- Cure, WISH
- Cranberries, EVERYONE ELSE IS DOING IT
- Suzanne Vega, DAYS OF OPEN HAND
- Psychedelic Furs, WORLD OUTSIDE
- XTC, NONSUCH
- My Bloody Valentine, LOVELESS
- Lush, SPOOKY
- Tears for Fears, ELEMENTAL
- Sarah McLachlan, FUMBLING TOWARD ECSTACY
- The The, DUSK
- Radiohead, PABLO HONEY
- Love Spit Love, LOVE SPIT LOVE
- Radiohead, THE BENDS
- Suzanne Vega, NINE OBJECTS OF DESIRE
- Sixpence None the Richer, SIXPENCE NONE THE RICHER
- Tears for Fears, EVERYBODY LOVES A HAPPY ENDING
- Mew, FRENGERS
- Elbow, SELDOM SEEN KID
- Muse, BLACK HOLES AND REVELATIONS
- NAO, GRAPPLING HOOKS
- NAO, FOG ELECTRIC
- Vertica, HAUNTED SOUTH
What am I missing?
Seems a great deal of this could be considered prog… but then again, that’s the beauty of progressive rock. It transcends genres. Any room for Al Stewart in your list? For some reason iTunes considers him pop, when I think he has more in common with Big Big Train than Madonna.
I must say, since you’ve shared Songs from the Big Chair through Dropbox, I’ve come to really enjoy the album. I’m not a big 80s fan, but it is really good. Interestingly, Disturbed covered “Shout” on their first album. Not all that surprising, though, considering the other covers Disturbed has done (Land of Confusion, I Still Haven’t Found What I’m Looking For, Sound of Silence, and probably others I’m forgetting – all covers I like more than the originals).
LikeLiked by 1 person
How about some Go Betweens or Grant McLennan’s criminally overlooked “Horsebreaker Star”?
LikeLiked by 1 person
Fascinating list, Brad. Fun! How would distinguish between “pop” and “rock”? And how does that play into your list? By the way, I’m especially fascinated that you have two Radiohead albums–but neither is “OK Computer”! That it’s in my Top 10, and I’ve been thinking about it a bit since this summer marks the 20th anniversary of its release.
LikeLiked by 1 person
Carl, I had to make just judgment calls. So, I’m labeling OK COMPUTER and DISINTEGRATION as prog.
LikeLiked by 1 person
Some suspect ones on my list? LOW LIFE could’ve been rock. STEELTOWN, too.
LikeLike
Another hard one is Simple Minds. NEW GOLD DREAM is rather clearly pop. But, SPARKLE IN THE RAIN might be straight rock.
LikeLike
I’m considering ORIGIN OF SYMMETRY as prog.
LikeLiked by 1 person
What are you missing?
Human League, Travelogue
Human League, Dare
Yahoo, Upstairs at Eric’s
Depeche Mode, singles album
Dire Straits, Makin Movies
Tori Amos, Little Earthquakes
The Police, Outlandos Damour
Siouxsie and the Banshees, The Scream
Al Stewart, The Year Of The Cat
T.Rex, Electric Warrior
Pauline Murray, and the Invisible Girls
LikeLiked by 2 people
Thanks, Dave. I know about half of these. Much appreciated.
LikeLike
That yahoo should have been yazoo. Predictive text strikes again.
LikeLike
Stuck in the 80’s much, Brad? 😉 I would (and have many times) recommend PREFAB SPROUT’s ‘Steve McQueen album. Excellent melodies tempered with amazing lyrics. i’d say most of my favourite albums of the pop kind are stuck in the 70’s and 80’s with a dab or two of the 60’s.
LikeLiked by 1 person
I turned 13 in 1980, Paul!
LikeLike
Pingback: One CEO’s 50 (or so) favorite pop albums | Progarchy
Great list, Brad, looks *very* close to what I would have chosen! 🙂 cheers, Robin
LikeLiked by 1 person
Robin, would you make one for us? I’d love to post it.
LikeLiked by 1 person
Sure, will see what I can come up with! 🙂
LikeLike
Kate bush♡
LikeLike