Interview with THE UNDER

The Under

Boston power trio, The Under released their second self-titled EP this June. Singer and guitarist Dan Costa talked with Progarchy about the band’s music, influences, inspiration.

Describe the music of The Under.

I think I would say it’s a metal band with no agenda. We don’t try to conform to a specific style, nor do we set out to incorporate anything particular into our writing. It’s three guys with a healthy music catalog who set out to do some heavy, expressive stuff.

Tell me about the complexities of creating your recently released self-titled EP? 

A lot of the songs were written in the jam space over the last few years, so the arrangements you hear is what we went into the studio with. The recording process itself was not very complex, but writing the songs certainly took some time.

How long did it take you to complete the work on “The Under” EP? 

It took the better part of a year because not long after we started recording we had to recruit a new bassist and we had yet to lay down the bass. Our drummer Randy knocked his parts out in a day and over the next month or so I went back and did the guitars and leads. Then Ben finally joined and over the next few weeks he would learn a tune and then we’d go into the studio to lay down the bass tracks. During that time I was recording the vocals on my own so that I’d have the time to capture the performances I want.

How come there are two releases under the name “The Under”? 

Because the first EP was our recording debut, we thought it was appropriate to self-title it. However, I had my eye on using the artwork that we settled on for the second EP, which came from an old flier. We just thought “why add anything to something that already jumps out at you?”. So we just left it as it was.

The Under cover

What can you tell me about the new songs comparing with 2009′s album “Mercurial”? 

Ultimately, I think all those songs could co-exist on the same recording. Because it often feels like our songs write themselves, you get a similar amount of variation on both discs. I do think the newer songs have a bit more of a bite and a crunch to them that might be lacking on Mercurial. But aside from the fact that we recorded and mastered them in two different locations, the songs all kin to each other.

Give me a snapshot of the topics you explore on the new songs. 

The songs tend to have a philosophical, existentialist slant to them. I think a common theme is the individual versus different types of mechanisms, such as society or time for example. Some tunes express an attitude of triumph while others touch on the despair and anxiety certain institutions can bring.

How would you describe your music to someone who didn’t hear you before? 

I’d probably ask them what they enjoyed listening to and go from there. If I had to do a quick pitch, I’d say we’re a loud, heavy band with a lot of melodic and rhythmic peaks and valleys.

Which bands  influence your work? 

I think as a band we channel a lot classic Rush, Sabbath and Zeppelin but with a strong injection of thrash, punk, jazz, hardcore and indie/experimental rock. ELP, Slayer, Black Flag, Don Caballero, Genesis, Iron Maiden, DRI, Metallica, Carcass, Jeff Buckley can make their influences heard in our music.

The Under

Where do you draw inspiration from? 

I think I speak for the other guys in that music has long been a reflex, something you have to do to process the things that go on in the world and in your life. So overall, we’re always inspired to play and write. But for me I would say reading a good book or going to an art museum can certainly get the creativity flowing in new ways.

Name five albums that had huge impact on the musical direction of The Under.

I’m the only one picking these 5 but I’m going to say:

Kill Em All-Metallica

Hemispheres-Rush

Led Zeppelin-Physical Graffiti

Black Sabbath-Black Sabbath

Piece of Mind-Iron Maiden

Where do you see The Under in the future?

We just hope to be writing, recording and playing live as we have been doing. We’re a bit past the whole big rock star thing and more focused on music as art and expression. Trying to write and play a little better than we did yesterday is a very satisfactory goal at the moment.

The Under’s new self-titled EP is available from Bandcamp. Follow the band on Facebook.

Album Spotlight: Porcupine Tree – “Fear of a Blank Planet”

What is truly important to you?

http://theprogmind.com/2015/09/04/album-spotlight-porcupine-tree-fear-of-a-blank-planet/

Better Know a Bookseller: Subterranean Books, St. Louis

Better Know a Bookseller is a new feature on this blog where we’ll introduce one of our wonderful stockists. Previously we have covered Harvard Book Store, Papercuts J.P., and Skylight Books. Publishing this series is only half the battle, and the booksellers in these stores all over the world really help keep us alive. If you are […]

http://333sound.com/2015/09/09/better-know-a-bookseller-subterranean-books-st-louis/

Incoming! The Ritchie Blackmore Story (2DVD/2CD)

**Before we start, I have retired the How Tempting tag for the time being. As these posts no longer concern my music-buying addictions and angst, the How Tempting title no longer really fits so any release news will now be under the Incoming! tag** Here’s an upcoming release that manages to bring together a lot […]

http://heavymetaloverload.com/2015/09/09/incoming-the-ritchie-blackmore-story-2dvd2cd/

Disturbed Covers “The Sound of Silence”

After a long hiatus, Chicago metal band Disturbed secretly recorded their latest album, Immortalized, which came out towards the end of last month. It was well worth the several year wait. While it isn’t really progressive (well, the song about weed could be considered “progressive,” but that would be a different connotation of the word), the band experiments in a couple new directions. They retain their awesome, heavy sound, while dropping in some keyboard sounds that add to the overall layering.

What struck me most about the album, however, was their cover of Simon and Garfunkel’s “The Sound of Silence.” This cover is more of a David Draiman (lead singer of Disturbed) cover than a Disturbed cover, because there are no metal elements at all. It is just him singing with symphonic music, with a little bit of acoustic guitar. He demonstrates his fantastic vocal abilities, in a way unlike any other Disturbed song he has made, and he brings just enough of his signature grit to the song without overdoing it. I like this version more than the original! I’ll admit, it gave me chills. Check it out.

Interview with HOMBRE BESTIA

Hombre Bestia

Hombre Bestia is a band that promotes a broader conscience by painting humans as fundamentally dual beings. Violence, love, war and art are simply some of the consequences of the inner clash between reason and instinct.

Drawing from genres such as progressive rock, metal, alternative, and psychedelic rock; and supported by introspective and social lyrical content, Hombre Bestia’s act is a reflection of constant movement: from the purest silence to the most chaotic noise.

The band from Mexico City will release a new EP titled “Janus” this fall, which will include acoustic versions of songs from the band’s 2013 full-length debut “Claroscuro,” but also previously unreleased tracks. Bassist Alejandro de Buen talks about the band’s beginnings, the new EP, live performances, and more.

Tell me about the band’s beginnings. How did you go about forming the band?

The band was formed by Bruno (Alexei) and Santos around five years ago, taking common musical influences and topics of interest that they had from long ago (they are friends since childhood) as the foundation for the band. Originally, the centerpoint of the band’s lyrical focus was the duality of man, the clash between reason (The Man) and instinct (The Beast).

Little by little the lineup started to adjust itself to include the rest of us, until the whole band had a unified vision of what we wanted to do and how, taking the aforementioned internal clash as a starting point to create our sound and derive our lyrical vision towards a broader perspective.

What does the name of the band mean, and how does it reflect to the music you make?

The name literally translates to Beast Man, and it aims towards reflecting the constant clash, which can be both struggle and synergy, of the forces of reason and instinct that drive us as species.
Musically, we try to balance extremes: tense, heavy and visceral stuff with calm, quiet and very harmonic cuts, so we think the name describes the music quite well. We try to make music that’s both introspective and direct, that speaks to the mind and the gut.

Tell me about the topics you explore in your lyrics.

Dualities are a recurrent topic for us, but we try to go beyond simply that. We try to use this perspective to talk about human nature in general, and to give our lyrics a social twist without falling into common places. We like to talk about society and dreams, and like to aim our lyrics towards working as a wake up call to people, a scream to make you look around yourself and realize the darkness and the light that surround us.

Janus EP art
Janus EP art

You are about to release a 6-track EP. What was the creative process for this material like? What can we expect from it?

A honest answer would be that it was polarized. There are two previously unrecorded tracks. The first one, Coro del Adios, is brand new, and reflects the most collaborative musical process within the band to date. It really shows a little of everyone. The other is one of the oldest songs in Hombre Bestia’s history (back from the Bruno-and-Santos-only days), but it has evolved a little every time we bring it back, until the point where it sounds more current than the first album. Both tracks flowed quite easily and enjoyably (though both had a slow evolution, the second one being obviously way slower!), but since both were born at such different times for the band, the process felt really different.

The rest of the tracks are acoustic recreations of already released tracks, which were quite fun to make because it took us out of our comfort zone (distortion and soundscapes!) and let us have a fresh way to play songs we’ve been playing non-stop for a long time.

How would you describe your music to someone who didn’t listen to you before?

The keywords contrast, introspection, and viscerality would come to mind. There’s a blend between prog, psychedelic rock, and small hints of metal, I think there’s also a very subtle latin touch somewhere in the mix, and there’s a huge amount of passion and honesty, which I’d say are our two main drivers.

What’s the point of Lalo’s covering his eyes in the video for “Matar Por Ti”? What is the story of the song?

The one covering his eyes is actually Bruno. The song, sometimes misinterpreted as a love song, is not dedicated to a person but to our country. In our case, Mexico which suffers from a lot of political abuse and inequity, and many times the problem is that both people in power and civil society seem to refuse to see this fact and the damage it is doing to all of us, condemning us to stay in this position. The veil over Bruno’s eyes is a way to convey this general refusal to actually see the current situation.

Fake Dreams is the only song on the EP that is sung in English. Do you have plans for releasing more songs in English?

Fake Dream was born in English because of the huge amount of English-spoken musical influences we have. Santos wrote it and it felt great that way, but we have only written music in Spanish since then, having a huge majority of Spanish-speaking followers and currently focusing our act nationally, as well as Spanish being our mother tongue.

We haven’t discussed any plans to write more music in English but I wouldn’t say we are closed to that possibility. If it feels good and honest to do so at some point, I think we could definitely do it again.

You’ve performed live before. What are the reactions from audiences like on your music? Are you satisfied with the reception you receive?

In general we are satisfied. It is not uncommon to see people seem to daze away at our shows, which we really dig because it shows they are really getting into it. When you play a quiet part and notice that the crowd is in utter silence, you know you really have them. Sometimes we would like to see more people reach deeper into the lyrics, but I guess that takes time and more listens.

Hombre Bestia

Are there any plans to present your music to Europeans?

There are few things we would love as much as playing in the Old Continent, though there are no current plans for a European tour (soon, hopefully!). Still, we feel there’s a bigger interest in our style over there, so with this new EP and with future releases, we are trying to push our music to reach European audiences and hopefully get that to get our plans closer to jumping the Atlantic.

Which bands influence your music?

As a band, some well-known names in the progressive scene, such as Riverside, Opeth, Tool, Porcupine Tree, Karnivool, and Steven Wilson; some modern and classic rock legends like Deep Purple, Black Sabbath and Alice in Chains, and some awesome bands from Mexico and the rest of Latin America like La Barranca, Soda Stereo, Caifanes, San Pascualito Rey and Cafe Tacvba. Individually tough, each of us draws from things as distant as Jeff Buckley, Nine Inch Nails, Screaming Headless Torsos, Angra, and Joy Division (it could be a fun exercise to try and guess who’s who!).

Follow Hombre Bestia on Facebook.

Renman Live: Lava Records and Jason Flom

 

LAVA RECORDS FOUNDER JASON FLOM TO GUEST ON “RENMAN LIVE” THIS WEEK
Tune in live to join the conversation!
LOS ANGELES – Renman Music & Business, the music industry mentoring website founded by longtime industry veteran, Steve Rennie (aka “Renman”), will broadcast the next episode of its Renman Live web show tomorrow, Wednesday, September 9, with special guest, Lava Records founder Jason Flom. This week’s show will air live at 10:00 a.m. PDT / 1:00 p.m. EDT on Renman Music & Business at: http://live.renmanmb.com and on the Renman MB YouTube channel at: https://www.youtube.com/user/renmanmb. Head over to Renman Music & Business at: http://www.renmanmb.com/articles/ar-legend-jason-flom-returns-to-renman-live for more info and to submit questions in advance. Viewers can also ask questions live on air by calling the Renman Live hotline: 1-310-469-9067 during the show.
Commented Rennie: “People ask me all the time how you learn the music biz. Simple. Hang out with smart people.
“On my web show, Renman Live, I’ve been lucky to have had some of the smartest, most talented people in the music biz join me to share their stories, insights and advice with aspiring artists and music pros who are dreaming of doing something big on their own and need some inspiration and direction. If you are interested in the music biz, watching an episode of Renman Live is the next best thing to sitting on the couch with me and my guests.”
Guests who have appeared on the 100-plus Renman Live broadcasts include Alex Lifeson (Rush), Pretty Lights, Brandon Boyd (Incubus), Andy Biersack (Black Veil Brides), Paul Tollett (Founder, Coachella), Charles Attal (Promoter, Lollapalooza), Kevin Lyman (Founder, Warped Tour), Troy Carter (Manager, John Mayer), Richard Griffiths (Manager, One Direction), Pat Magnarella (Manager, Green Day), Tom Corson (President, RCA), Mike Caren (President A&R, Warner Bros), Jeff Castelaz (President, Elektra Records), Aaron Bay-Schuck (President A&R, Interscope/Geffen/A&M) and many more.
All past episodes of Renman Live are now available in audio podcast form on iTunes at:https://itunes.apple.com/us/podcast/renman-live/id1005178582?mt=2 and can be streamed on YouTube at:https://www.youtube.com/playlist?list=PLaCGuUBKBfsuEGSchAEyI9fFuMXzJVuun.
-###-
About Steve Rennie…

Over the last 36 years, Renman Music & Business mastermind, Steve Rennie, has become one of the most successful and respected professionals in today’s music business. He has amassed a broad swath of experience as a concert promoter (Sr. VP Avalon Attractions now Live Nation 1984-1990), record company executive (Sr. VP GM Epic Records 1994-1998), internet entrepreneur (ArtistDirect 1998-2000) and artist manager (Incubus 1998-2014). Now, he is dedicating himself to mentoring this next generation of artists and music pros who will shape the music industry of the future.

Earlier this year, Rennie launched Renman U, an online course designed to be “an insider’s guide to today’s music business”: www.renmanu.com. Once enrolled, Renman U students receive an interactive set of online video lessons designed to teach aspiring artists and music business professionals what it takes to succeed in the music industry. Course lessons are based on Rennie’s more than 36 years of experience at the highest levels in the business, and include quizzes, written exams and more. An introductory Renman U video can be seen on YouTube: http://youtu.be/Q-GQyl5zNk8, while a free demo is available at: http://renmanu.com/course/renman-u-free-demo/.

Steve Rennie founded Renman Music & Business: http://www.renmanmb.com in 2012, an online education portal for the music industry featuring a YouTube channel: http://www.youtube.com/user/renmanmb with over 500 video clips with tips from industry pros, a web show, Renman Livehttps://www.youtube.com/playlist?list=PLaCGuUBKBfsuEGSchAEyI9fFuMXzJVuun, which has livestreamed over 100 episodes so far, and more.
Renman Music & Business online…

www.renmanmb.com

www.renmanu.com

www.facebook.com/RenmanMB

www.youtube.com/user/renmanmb

https://twitter.com/renmanmb

http://instagram.com/renmanmb

Interview with SOUND STRUGGLE

Sound Struggle-rs
Sound Struggle-rs

Prog funkers (yeah, you read it right!) from Boston, Sound Struggle are definitely one of my most favourite new bands, and I cannot wait to hear their second studio album “Rise” once it’s out on September 25th. The band has been active since 2012, and in June last year they came up with the full-length self-titled debut album. The six-piece band from the Massachusetts largest city are ready to take on the prog world with “Rise,” and bassist Joe Calderone and singer and guitarist Cameron Rasmussen talked with Progarchy about this.

Tell me about the Sound Struggle beginnings.

Cam: It started with me realizing that at Berklee College of Music it is very hard to be inducted and accepted into a band or other kind of group that has already been rolling for a while, or at all, and if you could you would have to really like the music they were making. That made me start from scratch on my own band that would be exactly what I wanted and would have the people I wanted in it.

The main idea behind what I wanted it to be was a very heavy metal band with improvised solos that have lots of jazz influence. I like to play a lot of jazz and jazz influenced things, so when I solo I like to steal from those influences and the harmonic vocabulary from that. I had some songs already somewhat written and had other ideas that I flushed out onto sheet music scores and charts for different guys to read through when I was finding the first lineup that the band would function with. From that starting point we have evolved to “Rise”!

Funk and prog metal – that’s a really crazy combination. Where did this idea come from and how much of a challenge it is to mix these two genres?

Joe: It’s a really fun combo. Funk and metal were both styles that we were all really interested in and enjoyed listening to and playing. The two styles can be melded different ways too. So I don’t think there is much of a challenge, because were just combining our biggest musical influences into our songs, the influences just happen to be a pretty diverse spectrum of styles.

Rise

You are about to release your new album titled “Rise.” What can we expect from the record, and how does it differ from the self-titled debut?

Joe: On the first album the interpretation was very much straight Funk section, and in the same son straight metal section, and they were a bit disconnected. On Rise we really took a more integrated approach, where the funk comes from something like the guitarists doubling thumbing guitar like Victor Wooten, but in a metal context, or possibly using jazz and funk harmony on a metal riff.

Cam: Yes it’s more of a fluid and integrated approach as opposed to the almost bi-polar method of the first album.

What kind of gear did you use to record “Rise”?

Joe: We used whatever we could find. All the guitar and bass, and even some EWI (electronic wind instrument) parts were recorded through a Fractal Axe FX II. I recorded most of the album on my trusty Fender Geddy Lee signature jazz bass, downtuned to A-E-A-D. The guitars were done with a Strandberg Boden OS 7, a custom Carvin 7, a Fender Strat, a Yamaha Nylon String acoustic, and a few other guitars thrown in. Joey loves the sounds on his Motif piano, and you’ll hear a lot of them, but there are also a few soft synths being used too from plugins like Massive. Another change from the last album is the introduction of the EWI. Since we don’t have a full horn section anymore, Mike will switch between a tenor sax and an EWI, and the EWI really expands what he can contribute musically. It’s been a really cool addition to the sound. Joey also engineered the drums to perfection and we used whatever mics the studio had to get a great drum sound.

How does the name of the band reflect on the music you create?

Cam: Well we originally picked Sound Struggle because it was the right mix of serious sounding and comedic value to describe the music we were playing. The “Struggle” is just a funny comment on how we use all of the genres we like in our writing, whereas some people might still say nowadays that you should stick with one genre and that’s it. That doesn’t sound like much fun to me!

Cameron Rasmussen
Cameron Rasmussen

What was the toughest moment in the band’s career so far and how did you go about overcoming it?

Cam: The toughest part so far was probably members leaving the band or having to let people go. We have had a few members who we were really happy with, like the first solid lineup that we played our first show with, but a few of them had to leave because they needed jobs elsewhere or went to other colleges. We really miss those guys like. I have also had to kick a bunch of guys out, which is never fun, but if its not working its no fun for anybody.

To overcome it we just did our best to find people who would be killer players and friends at the same time, and when we were short on people we got whatever work we could get done, done, so that we weren’t sitting around waiting for new members. Not having a band makes having a band a really hard thing to do. (laughs)

Joe Calderone
Joe Calderone

I have watched all videos you uploaded on YouTube, and it seems that you guys have lots of fun. Does funk make it easy for you?

Joe: Well it’s all fun! We really enjoy playing funk, and we really enjoy playing metal so we’re always having fun. The metal riffs are challenging enough to keep us on our feet, and the improvisational funk sections are just inherently jammable and entertaining to us.

Name five albums that had huge impact on the musical direction of Sound Struggle.

Cam: Probably:

1. Vulgar Display of Power – Pantera
2. Ego – Alex Argento
3. Heavy Metal Be-Bop – The Brecker Brothers
4. Silent Machine – Twelve Foot Ninja
5. The Joy Of Motion – Animals As Leaders

Are you satisfied with where you landed in the music scene?

Cam: Yes, I think we all are! Earlier in the bands history we were wondering if we could market ourselves as a funk band, as well as a metal band, but we pretty much realized that …no. So, though our approach to music hasn’t changed we landed in a metal scene that we all really like!

Where do you see yourself in the future? Can you read your own story?

Cam: Well, every member of this band is a genius to me, and they all do so many things of their own outside of Sound Struggle, I do as well. I have a feeling that we will all support ourselves financially with our other skills while doing Sound Struggle in tandem in the months and years to come, until it becomes a big enough enterprise that we could call it our job.

If that happens sooner, then I’m positive we would be all over it!

What is your favourite beer?

Joe: I’m a sucker for Sam Adams, especially the seasonal stuff. Or anything brewed with chocolate and coffee.

Sound Struggle’s second studio album “Rise” is out on September 25th, stay tuned via Facebook and Bandcamp.

Freedom is Coming: MorseFest 2015

A review of MorseFest, 2015 (Friday night only)

With apologies--photos taken from an older iPhone. Not great quality.
With apologies–photos taken from an older iPhone. Not great quality.

Last Friday, September 4, as soon as I’d finished teaching my freshmen courses on Western Civilization, my wife, Dedra, and I got into the car and drove 8 hours south to Cross Plains, Tennessee, site of MorseFest 2015.  We had originally hoped to attend the entire weekend, but family necessities prevented this.  We were only going to be able to attend Friday night.

We made it by 7 (aided by a time change, gaining an hour), and found ourselves at a rather nice, contemporary Protestant church, just south of the Kentucky border.  Even walking across the parking lot, my wife and I realized this would not be the normal prog crowd.  Indeed, a huge variety of peoples was walking into the church—including lots of elderly women, immaculately dressed.  We had seen the Neal Morse Band play live in Denver in February to the usual prog crowd of mostly middle aged men.

As we walked into the lobby in Tennesse, we found fellow progarchist, Tad Wert, waiting for us.  He’s always a delight, and we thoroughly enjoyed our short time with him.

Ticketed, we took our seats toward the back of the church.  The church itself, as mentioned above, was quite nice, and quite comfortable.  By the time we sat, it was already mostly full with only the random open chair.  The three of us caught up with one another, and I even had a moment to introduce myself to Morse’s manager, Chris Thompson, president of Radiant.  I’ve corresponded and talked with Chris for over three years now, but we’d never met in actual person.  Lots of folks wanted to meet him, so I just got a quick hello in.

Chris was, frankly, everything I’d expected.  As warm and kind as he is proficient.  THIS is the man you want by your side, through thick and thin.  I already loved the guy, but actually meeting him and getting a rather spontaneous bear hug was one of many highlights of the weekend.  I’m truly sorry I didn’t get to spend more time with him.  He, of course, had a job to do, and he did it brilliantly.  He’s actually fun to watch work, as they guy so expertly takes charge and as a meter for excellence that runs higher than one rarely sees.  Thompson is the embodiment of joyful, purposeful intensity.

At 7:30, guitarist Phil Keaggy opened, playing for roughly 45 minutes.  I knew of Keaggy by name only, but I found his playing quite good and captivating.  He played roughly six songs, including two covers.  One cover was of the Beatles and another of Bob Dylan.  Keaggy was also quite funny and self-depreciating.  Certainly, the audience appreciated his humor and talents.  His guitar work, it must be noted, is rich and full bodied.  My favorite of his pieces was one called “Salvation Army Band.”

MorseFest, New Life Fellowship Church, Cross Plains, Tennessee.
MorseFest, New Life Fellowship Church, Cross Plains, Tennessee.

After a fifteen minute break, the Neal Morse Band took the stage, opening with the first two tracks off of THE GRAND EXPERIMENT (Radiant, 2015), “The Call”  and “The Grand Experiment.”  I had no idea Morse would play these.  The bill had advertised the full “?” album (Radiant, 2005), and I’d assumed this would be it.  No, I was very wrong.  The band’s third track was “Go the Way You Go” by Spock’s Beard.  Eric Gillette, an extraordinary talent by any measure, even walked into the audience and played a blistering solo.

As this point, I should note the crowd again.  Here, we were.  In a contemporary and comfortable Protestant Church.  The crowd adored Neal Morse and every member on the stage.  This was family, not an audience.  Elderly women and men—impeccably dressed—sat throughout the crowd, some in wheel chairs.  Kids listened for a while and then slept on the floor.  About 1/3 of the crowd raised their hands throughout the concert in what I assume is typical Pentecostal fashion, while another 1/3 head banged.  It was incredible.  Absolutely incredible.  The energy in that room was astounding for the entirety of the concert.  Absolutely incredible and astounding! Head-banging Pentecostals.

Our common denominator: we all consider Neal Morse one of the most gifted and charismatic artists on this earth.  His talent and his life are, to put it simply, nothing short of infectious. 

The next three tracks were “MacArthur Park,” “Whole Nother Trip,” and “New Jerusalem.”  The first and third are from the b-side disk of THE GRAND EXPERIMENT, and the middle track was from Morse’s second solo album, way back in the late 1990s.

For me, the highlight of the entire concert was “New Jerusalem.”  This is not only my favorite song on THE GRAND EXPERIMENT, it might very well be the finest thing Neal has ever written.  I was sorely disappointed the band didn’t play it in Denver, though I’d expected as much.  When it began in Cross Plains, I looked to my wife—in utter disbelief—and muttered, “no way.”  In fact, it probably took me a full minute to accept the band was playing it.

After these six tracks, the band played the entirety of the 2005 “?” album.

A few thoughts, in no particular order.

  • First, as many times as I’ve seen Morse and Portnoy play live, I’ve never seen them play this well.  There was nothing but love between the two men, and they so ably led the rest of the band as well as the audience.
  • Second, this setting was so intimate, that it was as though Morse had invited five hundred of his closest friends to his living room.
  • Third, and equally astounding to the music, was the film and light show.  Granted, good Protestant churches know how to do media well.  This church was no exception.  But, what made it so memorably good was the quality of the film made just for this concert (a one-off, it should be remembered).  The visuals were top-notch, Hollywood A-list quality.  The overall theme of the accompanying film was neo-psychedelia but carrying with it an intense Christian aura.  Imagine Franco Zeffirelli directing Charleton Heston but with Matrix-like special effects and you can somewhat imagine how good the accompanying film and light show were.  Kudos to whoever produced this.  Chris, was it you?
  • Fourth, staging.  One of the most interesting things Morse did was add new people to the concert as the music continued.  At first, it was just the five members of the Neal Morse Band.  Then, slowly, extra guitarists, string players, horn players, a flautist, percussionists, and a choir joined.  All of this built up in the first set to the climax with the playing of New Jerusalem.  By the end of that song, I couldn’t even count how many people were playing on stage.  Overwhelming and wonderfully so.
  • Fifth, I loved every moment of “?”  I’ve owned and listened to the album since the day it came out.  I’m not sure I’d understood it or its immense beauty, however, until seeing it played live.  I felt as though I was living for 58 minutes in the heart of a profound mystery with all existential questions being properly answered by love.  As with the album, Pastor Steve Farmer (this was in his church) came out and gave a brief homily.  It was appropriate and quite moving.

So, in sum: possibly the best prog experience of forty years of prog experiences.  I’m so sorry I wasn’t able to attend the rest of the weekend.  I won’t make this mistake again.  If I could, I’d already order my tickets for the next decade of MorseFests.