I love lists (top 10s, 20s, 100s whatnot) and “best-of” compilations. I think no source has given us a better view of the progressive gems of 2015 than Progarchy. My own opinions are just that—mine. While my “best of” judgment calls are ultimately just my favorite albums from the past year, I think I’ll stick with “best of” rather than “Watson’s Faves.” The music that you might think should be listed, but doesn’t appear here, more than likely means I just didn’t get a chance to listen to it. Dave Kerzner’s brilliant album is not listed because I view it (and first listened to it) as a 2014 release. I’ll skip posting album jacket photos and links. While the list is for “PROG” I also include a few other categories. It was a great year and this is how I saw it: [counting down in reverse order for greater surprise effect]
TOP 20 OF 2015 ALBUMS
- Beardfish/ +4626 COMFORTZONE
This band rarely disappoints. The music is riveting only trumped by some profound lyrics.
- Neal Morse/ GRAND EXPERIMENT
Morse has the ‘gold-standard’ for constantly producing beautiful and poignant music that emotionally engages the listener. In a less stellar year would be rated higher.
- Glass Hammer/ A BREAKING OF THE WORLD
Ditto my comments on Morse. Every GH album should be purchased as they’re incapable of making anything less than a jewel.
- The Gentle Storm/ DIARY
This is a great concept-story which was executed brilliantly in two versions (hard and soft). I’m a sucker for melody and when Anneke sings I hear hints of one of my favorite song-birds, Annie Haslam. A gorgeous and moving listen.
- Native Construct/ QUIET WORLD
A blend of heavier progressive rock and progressive metal with enough hooks and stunning harmonizations to make one say “who are these guys?” One my “finds” of the year.
- Steven Wilson/ HAND. CANNOT. ERASE
This was in my top three most of the year. What else can I add to what the known universe has been saying about Wilson’s magnum opus? Serious, sublime, reflective, and permanent in its impact. 10/10.
- The Dear Hunter/ ACT IV: REBIRTH IN REPRISE
The best reason not to come out with a “best of” list until the last day of the year is so that albums like this don’t slip by in the rush. I only just heard this concept disc (a couple days ago) and it has been listened to almost a dozen times now. This is a fulsome blend of Muse and maybe Coheed & Cambria. I must explore their back discography as their fusion of orchestra rock and classic prog, with a hint of art-rock/jazz, hit me so hard that they vaulted over even Steven Wilson. Along with Native Construct, this is a discovery that makes 2015 so epic.
- The Tangent/ A SPARK IN THE AETHER.
Andy and company turn out their best album yet (such an artist that every new release is their best one yet). Andy’s love of music and the progressive genre radiates out in warm love and celebratory life. This is a feel-good album that is returned to time and time again. Was in contention for #1.
- Lonely Robot/ PLEASE COME HOME
John Mitchell’s album is near perfect. The infectious melodies, lyrical themes, and exquisite musicianship had this loosely-based concept album of alienation and humanity neck and neck with the following winner.
THE BEST ALBUM OF 2015 – –
- 3RDegree/ ONES AND ZEROS: Vol. 1
If you are a fan of progressive masterpieces (Yes, King Crimson, Genesis, and Rush) you will quickly realize that 3RDegree’s ONES AND ZEROS will be talked about with the same enduring awe as the aforementioned masters of this art. The album is deep and disturbing with a libretto worthy of the best dystopian science-fiction legendary authors. The musicianship is tight and the album’s production and mixing is crisp. If I could have listened to only one album this past year (and a gander at my list makes clear what a bumper year it has been) it would have this one. I’m listening to it right now as I type. Go buy it. Buy copies for your friends…Christmas 2016 is only 12 months away…you’ll probably not find an album this good in those coming 12 months.
And now, to round out my TOP 20:
- Gazpacho/ Molok
- Spock’s Beard/THE OBLIVION PARTICLE
- Tiger Moth Tales/ STORY TELLERS PART ONE
- Argos/ A SEASONAL AFFAIR
- Barock Project/SKYLINE
- Arena/ THE UNQUIET SKY
- Red Jasper/ THE GREAT AND SECRET SHOW
- Grand Tour/ HEAVY ON THE BEACH
- Steve Hackett/ WOLFLIGHT
- Subterranean Masquerade/ THE GREAT BAZAAR
HONORABLE MENTION
Riverside/ LOVE, FEAR, AND THE TIME MACHINE
Sylvan/ HOME
Sanguine Hum/ NOW WE HAVE A LIGHT
David Gilmour/ RATTLE THAT LOCK
Toto/ XIV
BEST NON-PROG:
POP/ROCK/INDIE, ETC.
Joe Jackson/Fast Forward
FFS/ FFS
The Decemberists/ WHAT A TERRIBLE WORLD WHAT A BEAUTIFUL WORLD
Jeff Lynn’s ELO/ ALONE IN THE UNIVERSE
HEAVY METAL/SLUDGE/STONER/PSYCH ETC.
Iron Maiden/ BOOK OF SOULS
Baroness/ PURPLE
Amorphis/ UNDER THE RED CLOUD
Arcturus/ ARCTURIAN
Motorhead/ BAD MAGIC (Lemmy R.I.P)
The Sword/ HIGH COUNTRY
COUNTRY
Dwight Yoakum/ SECOND HAND HEART
Whitey Morgan and the 78’s/ SONIC RANCH
Chris Isaak/ FIRST COMES THE NIGHT
BEST SONGS
Choir of Ancestors/ Gazpacho
First Comes The Night/Chris Isaak
Hand Cannot Erase/ Steven Wilson
A Night on the Town/ The Dear Hunter
Waves/ The Dear Hunter
Till the End/ Motorhead
Collaborations Don’t Work/ FFS
Fast Forward/ Joe Jackson
The Celluloid Road/ The Tangent
The Boy in the Radio/ Lonely Robot
Bennett Built A Time Machine/ Spock’s Beard
Sacrifice/ Amorphis




Dunnery: I basically picked the most important songs on the albums, the ones that I liked. The ones that I felt could be sonically updated successfully. I’m a song guy. I’m not particularly interested in how fast someone can tap an arpeggio—I’m far more interested in melody, storytelling, and lyrics. When I was 18, I was more focused on musicianship, but today’s musicians are mostly performing little tricks…which is cool but it’s not something I’m interested in today. I always loved Paul McCartney, The Beach Boys, Prefab Sprout, The Blue Nile, Laura Nyro—song people. The songs I picked were probably the best melodies.
that is unmistakably Riverside. While the album still has some of their trademark moodiness, the darkness has been replaced with a mature, tempered, and realistic optimism that grows throughout. This album was quite a leap for Riverside in terms of direction, and yet they pulled it off flawlessly.
classic/symphronic prog sound of an earlier era, and yet sounds fresh and modern. It works especially well since Sylvan’s natural singing voice seems to be a perfect mix of Peter Gabriel and Phil Collins, making it no mystery as to why Steve Hackett selected him as a touring vocalist. Standout tracks on this album include the title track, Echoes of Ekwabet, and the excellent epic, To Turn The Other Side.
was really two albums in one, a heavy version (Storm) with all the songs “metaled up” by Arjen, and a lighter version (Gentle) which relied more heavily on acoustic instruments and folky sounds. Both are excellent and it’s tough to pick on. Shores of India seems to work best in the Gentle form, while The Storm, appropriately, seems to work best in the Storm version.
Because this album is the proggiest thing Iron Maiden has ever done, even though it retains their previous heavy metal elements. While this album is excellent from start to finish, the boys of Maiden are at their strongest here when they are on their proggiest – the 10 minutes plus title, track, the 13 minutes plus The Red and the Black, and the closing, 18 minute epic, Empire of the Clouds. For the shorter, more familiar Maiden, Speed of Light is a particularly strong track. I’ve always defended the members and the music of Iron Maiden as being more intelligent and thoughtful than that of their heavy metal peers, and this album is the best evidence yet of that. This is truly a crowning achievement on an amazing career.
excellent release, A Spark in the Aether. One of the things that really comes through on this album (and makes it so excellent) is that is sounds like Tillison was having tongs of fun in making it. The joy really shines through on one of my favorite tracks, Codpieces and Capes, a celebration of prog’s glorious past. Even better is The Celluloid Road, Andy’s insightful look at America through the lens provided in film, i.e. movies that is. It’s the highlight of an album full of highlights. Oh, and speaking of America …
better than I can remember in some time. For one, Echolyn returned with I Heard You Listening, which more or less picks up where they left off in 2012. There were no bad tracks on the album, but Messenger of All’s Right, Different Days, and All This Time We’re Given were especially strong.
evolves into new territory. I absolutely love the leadoff track, Snow Country, and am also partial to A Lottery and On Paper. The playing is top notch throughout. But what I like best about this album is the outstanding vocal performance of Leslie Hunt, who continues to make a strong case for the title of First Lady of Prog. Whether it’s her breathy jazz phrasing, her power vocals, or something in between, she hits it perfect every time.
I’m hoping that the Vol. 1 part of the title is an implicit stating that there will be a Vol. 2, because I definitely want more of this. A concept album that explores our relationship to technology (the digital world in particular), the lyrics are both clever and insightful. This one will be interesting to come back to five or ten years hence to examine the lyrics/concept in the context of how times will change.
Particle. I won’t mince words here – I think Leonard is the best vocalist Spock’s Beard has ever had, and I love where they are going with him at the mike. Bennett Built a Time Machine is an excellent track, and I love Minion as well (would have liked the move Minions to have worked a little prog into their soundtrack with this one …). They musicianship is as stellar as ever, and combined with Leonard’s voice, the Beard sounds as good as ever to these ears.
album was initially released in 2014, but after many had already compiled their year-end best-of lists. It didn’t seem fair to me that such a fine album wouldn’t make the cut simply because of the timing of its release. So I’m going to include it here as a 2015 release and put it on my list – and on the merits it most definitely belongs.














