A Few More Words on the Politics Thing

One of our esteemed founders, Dr. Birzer, has had a few excellent posts today on the intersection of art and politics, in part to a reaction of some recent releases and in larger part in reaction to some larger trends.  In reading them, I had about 1.5 cents of my own I wanted to throw in.

This isn’t to say I don’t ever like political subject matter intertwined with music.  But some ways of doing it are more appealing than others.  One of my favorite albums this year – Galahad’s sprawling, incredible Seas of Change – is very political in its lyrics.  It’s focused on the tumult in the U.K. over Brexit.  However, which side of that debate it eventually comes down upon is hard to say.  I’ve read reviews that say it’s pro-Brexit, others that say it’s anti-Brexit.  When I pore over the lyrics, I come away with … I don’t know.  It seems like Galahad has plenty to critique on both sides of that debate.  Irrespective of that, one of the things I like about it is that it takes a “clean up your own backyard first” approach.  Nobody is doing a Roine Stolt on Lost America here, sitting back smugly criticizing another polity as if theirs is somehow perfect.  The path Galahad has chosen is one of self-reflection, the one chosen by Stolt is cheap, smug, self-superiority.  Galahad’s path is engaging (as is Marillion’s FEAR), Stolt’s is off-putting.

Stolt isn’t the only sinner here.  Andy Tillison and The Tangent really stepped in it with their previous album, The Slow Rust of Forgotten Machinery.  In the final track of that album, Andy rails on all things British politics in relation to the turmoil of Brexit, the driving factors by those in favor of the same, and the general turmoil of 2016.  At the end of the song, after 15+ minutes of bait, he pulls the switch, complete with German accents and a comparison of the pro-Brexiteers with Nazis (Heinrich Himmler, in particular).  It has all the subtlety of a lecture by Professor Turgeson; it has all the artistry of an alcoholic vomiting out the night’s intake in the parking lot.  It has about the same amount of persuasive power.

You don’t persuade somebody by likening them to an infamous Nazi and architect ofhitlerbook history’s worst crimes against humanity (especially when your own guitarist wears a hipster T-shirt of another one of history’s great butchers, Che Guevera – whose own racist views would have made the Nazis proud).  Not only does it fail to make those see your point, it actually accomplishes the opposite.  The people you think you are trying to reach become hardened in the position you are trying to persuade them from.  But hey, it makes you feel good, doesn’t it?  You can totally ignore the fact that they might have valid reasons for feeling the way they do, and instead accuse them of, e.g., dehumanizing migrants while you dehumanize them as Nazis for disagreeing with you.  Projection ain’t just a river in Egypt, is it?

I’m also going to let a little bit of my own national pride into the picture.  I get sick and tired of all the America-bashing.  It seems to be one of those things – like overt sexuality – that artists run to when they are out of other ideas.  But hey, it’s edgy, right?

And to bolster the point of one of Brad’s posts reference above, we get sick and tired of politics being injected into everything, especially with the sanctimonious in-your-face way it’s practiced, including by those I’ve critiqued above.  Some of you on the other side of the pond (and most of you on this side) might be familiar with the national anthem protests by players as NFL games, started by Mr. Sacrifice Everything, Colin Kaepernick (who couldn’t be bothered to sacrifice his free time for film study or extra coaching to work on his throwing mechanics, both of which are exceedingly important for an NFL quarterback).  Some of us might agree with the (stated) cause, that bad cops need to be held accountable (although that particular protest quickly devolved into something less).  But there is a time and a place for it though.  When I sit down to watch football, I want to watch football and not have politics shoved in my face.  Similarly when I want to consume art, I want art – not cheap political posturing, self-righteous preening, and poor, clichéd substitutes for actual creativity.

And no, nobody’s trying to censor you (a retort I would fully expect if I didn’t just write that).  You have a right to say what ever you want.  But you can be damn sure we are going to exercise our right to say something back.  And we also have a right to not buy your BS – or your albums.  Suck it up, buttercup.

13 thoughts on “A Few More Words on the Politics Thing

  1. Erik, who has been my good cyber pal (and FB pal too) for quite a while now, says everything I wish I had said. But, Erik says it better than I could and with more deftness, charity, and articulateness. He is my Prog-reviewer HERO!!!

    Liked by 4 people

      1. One other comment, and then I’ll shut up for the night. Do these folks in Europe and the UK think we like being bashed all of the time. At some point, aren’t they expecting us to argue back? I’m still scratching my head at Stolt’s comment that he’s not taking a jab at us. How is that even possible?

        Liked by 1 person

      2. Erik Heter

        To that, I will add another question- if some American band did songs or albums bashing the UK or Europe, would they take offense? Maybe it’s happened, but I sure can’t think of any music like that off the top of my head.

        I do know a lot of English were offended by Mel Gibson with both Braveheart and The Patriot, but music? I can’t think of any.

        Liked by 1 person

  2. Bryan Morey

    Great points, Erik. I must say, I don’t know of any other website or publication that calls attention to this issue. This is just one of many ways Progarchy is a fantastic website that I’m proud to be a part of. I know we have writers here that may disagree with those of us that have been more vocal about this, and I certainly hope they feel open to express their opinions as well… and I hope they do.

    Liked by 2 people

  3. MrDreamTheater2

    If you call an average liberal a communist, they’ll laugh at you and recognize that as hyperbole (which it is). So why do so many of them have no problem with calling center-right types Nazis and fascists? Is it just because they don’t know how to argue besides blurting out magic words, or is it because they have so much of their ego invested in politics, they get furious when others don’t agree with them and need to cause maximum amounts of feelbad?

    If capitalism is of “the right,” then Nazism is not even “far right” to begin with, since fascism was devised by Mussolini as a “third way” between capitalism and communism (and the anti-Semitism was Hitler’s addition specifically). The Political Compass Site, which has a known left-libertarian bias, actually classifies Hitler as only slightly to the right, but very authoritarian.

    Whether you look at the NFL, video games, comic books, or science fiction (like the new Star Wars movies), leftist social justice warriors have been the ones consistently trying to shove politics into arts and entertainment. I believe these sorts of leftists have very low self-esteem (particularly guilt and shame feelings) and, for reasons which are too complex to describe in a blog comment, use “causes” like feminism and racial equity to mask these feelings.

    There are legitimate criticisms you can make of America, but the constant America-bashing emanating from the left is because America is powerful, successful, and for a time anyway, had a strong sense of its own superiority (American exceptionalism). Leftists hate Donald Trump for much the same reasons – he’s successful, rich, braggadocious, and confident – but they use his alleged disdain for women and immigrants as a front.

    Liked by 1 person

  4. Richard Lock

    Can I offer a crumb of reassurance from the UK by saying that not everyone here is jumping on the easy bandwagon of nation bashing. Whichever nation. There’s certainly no need to reciprocate and fall into the trap of joining rather than beating. If people, and I include songwriters here, can’t see that issues are far more complex than their easy, and lazy assumptions then distancing your self from their output is the only viable option. I was mightily relieved to read the missive above about The Tangent because it’s about time someone said something about the very worst example of blinkered, idiotic ranting I think I’ve ever heard presented in a song. Comparing anything with the depravities of Nazi Germany is a hideous misappropriation of both fact and context. By contrast, your flagging of Galahad’s writing about the EU referendum shines light on how to deliver an observation with balance. This deserves more exposure. Applaud and support the artists that apply a degree of critical thinking and consign those that don’t to the bargain bin.

    Liked by 1 person

Thoughts?

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s