2017, another great year for prog passionistas!

Jargon 2
From Athens with love – Jargon of Verbal Delirium


2017 – what a year it has been for prog. Against the backdrop of some highly perplexing and disturbing events across the world’s stage, but, to quote the title of Paul Stump’s excellent assessment of prog, The Music’s All That Matters.

On a personal note, it has been a particularly challenging year, having early on developed a stress-related condition due to pressures presented by a previous employer, which led to an emergency operation and a month’s recuperation.  This was coupled with seeing a parent being subsumed in the clutches of dementia. However, equilibrium was restored in the latter part, thanks to the kindness, belief and support of many people both inside and outside the prog bubble.

Though prevailing conditions resulted in me missing several high profile happenings, including HRH Prog in March, 2017 has continued to astound and astonish with the quality of the music being produced, and also the wonderful community of people. This is the tribe that cherishes and follows prog in individual capacities from the fans and supporters, to the writers, the promoters, the merchandise sellers, the record label owners and of course, the artistes themselves, most of whom make scant financial returns on their considerable investments of time and energy. As was originally stated, the music is all that matters.

Without further ado, here are the highlights, and some of the lowlights, which made 2017 another great year for us prog passionistas.

Top Albums:

1) The Slow Rust of Forgotten Machinery – The Tangent. As one of prog’s most outspoken savants, Andy Tillison brings profound political and social commentary into the narrative of this musically outstanding album. This is a clarion call to wake up and see how our perceptions of the world are being manipulated. Some stellar musicianship peaks on Dr Livingstone (I Presume), co-written by his brilliant fellow Tangential collaborator Luke Machin. Thoughtful, profound with hints of jazz and dance-trance, it also features some extraordinary hard hitting artwork by DC Comics cartoonist, Mark Buckingham.

2) In The Passing Light of Day – Pain of Salvation. This is a band whose music I usually equate to being mentally mugged. However,  it is full of emotion and anguish expressed through the travails of charismatic frontman Daniel GildenlöwThis is all about  the unimaginable journey he experienced during his close brush with death when he contracted  a flesh-eating bug; this created an intensity and intimacy within this album  which is hard to resist.

3) Grimspound – Big Big Train. Going off on a slightly different track, Big Big Train mined a new seam of beautiful story-led songs, introducing us to new personae dramatis, including Captain Cook, the Brave Captain, Experimental Gentlemen and the inhabitants of the Mead Hall. However, it is the folkie beauty and simplicity of The Ivy Gate featuring Judy Dyble which really clinches it here.

4) On Track – Damanek. One of the surprise packages of the year came from this richly talented musical ensemble led by Guy Manning. The understated, perceptive way it goes about its business, offering some coruscating commentary about the state of the world and the wonders of the night sky is compelling and joyous.

5) = Cardington – Lifesigns. Having released one of prog’s greatest debuts in 2013, John Young took his time to deliver that tricky second album. And deliver it does, but in a very clever, subtle way. Full of passion, melody and some killer hooklines, it reels you in and delights you with every play.

5) =  The Bride Said No – Nad Sylvan.  Prog’s Beau Brummel enhanced his reputation as a distinctive singer, composer and solo artist with a gorgeous collection of songs. These include two of this year’s most memorable, The Quartermaster and When The Music Dies, in which his theatrical sensibilities really come to the fore.

Talking Heads Progarchy
Red Bazar/Tiger Moth Tales at the Talking Heads in Southampton

Highlights of the Year:

  • Big Big Train cementing their reputation as the consummate prog band with their three amazing shows at the Cadogan Hall in London. There were sound issues on the opening night but once these were overcome, there was no disputing the incredible power and innate beauty of their music which reduced many grown men in the audience to mush. Especially touching was dedicating Meadowland to John Wetton, whose wife Lisa was in the audience.
  • Franck Carducci bringing the house down at Summer’s End. Going on after Frost*, he and his band of players offered the unsuspecting audience the prog equivalent of a big top circus. It was sexy, funny, colourful and totally over the top. Everybody went home with a huge smile on their face.
  • Tangekanic at Summer’s End offering an incredibly well-measured and beautiful performance. Nobody there will ever forget Andy Tillison’s extraordinary solo piece Sanctuary. This was written  in memory of the music fans who were murdered in Manchester and Las Vegas after two disparate deranged, cowardly individuals decided that predominantly young people having the time of their lives were an easy target to forward their twisted personal agendas. Moving in extremis.
  • The emergence of Talking Heads in Southampton as an excellent provincial south coast venue, attracting some class acts throughout the year including Tiger Moth Tales/Red Bazar, Magenta and the Von Hertzen Brothers.
  • A personal memory was of Tom Newman, legendary producer of Tubular Bells, coming on stage during a performance of Sanctuary with Robert Reed and his brilliant ensemble at the Parabola Arts Centre in Cheltenham. This was heightened further with the great man  mistaking Martin (my husband) for his old mate, Gordon Giltrap!
  • Meeting up again with Michael Sadler, frontman of Canadian rockers Saga, after 36 years. Saga is one of those bands who never seemed to find a consistent audience in the UK. Mindful of the loyal band of fans in the UK, Michael made a special point of coming over to London to spend an informal afternoon meeting and chatting with around 15 of them. It was a lovely gesture by a superb performer and musician.
Franck Carducci Progarchy
Roll up, roll up – it’s Franck Carducci and his prog’n rock circus!


  • The spiralling price of gig tickets, putting many out of the reach of some prog fans. For example, the price of the Hammersmith Apollo tickets for Anderson, Wakeman and Rabin which were nudging the £100 mark which proved a deterrent.
  • Frost*, the official headliners on Saturday night at Summers End but opted to perform in the early evening slot. Granted, they had sound problems during their set but their  brusque “turn up, play and depart” attitude was noticed and remarked upon by many present. All the other bands, without exception, took time out to meet and mingle with fans, and sign merchandise.
  • Lazuli being unable to complete their much anticipated support slot on tour with Fish due to singer Domi Leonetti’s illness. Many people were so looking forward to seeing them again and, being the band they are, they will probably feel very deeply that they have let down both Fish and their fans. Few bands attract such genuine love and affection and rest assured, they will be back.
  • Ian Oakley, the Tangent’s stalwart, genial right hand person breaking his leg in two places while photographing Andy and Jonas by the iconic sign for Basildon a day after joining us here at Prog Cottage for some filming, photographing and laughs.
  • The disappointing turn-out at many gigs. The one which immediately springs to mind is the Midsummer Madness festival at the Bedford in Balham where several  quality bands were appearing, including the great Verbal Delirium, who had flown in from Greece to take part. The musicians in the bands present outnumbered the  entry-paying audience members who came along that afternoon.

5 thoughts on “2017, another great year for prog passionistas!

    1. John Wyant

      The crazy thing for me was that I had seen them at The Brook in Southampton not long before, and they absolutely blew the roof off – the sound was great, the set-list was to die for, it was genuinely one of my personal highlights of 2017. So I was totally bemused by their performance at Summers End, where the sound balance was just atrocious – you could barely hear some of the solos. And it wasn’t the hall – the regular sound guy who knows the place managed to make all the other bands sound great, so it was strange that Frost presumably insisted on using their own sound guy.


  1. Great wrapup! I can attest to The Bedford being the emptiest venue on our (3RDegree’s) 7-date one & only European tour in “15 as well. Jaded Londoners? New York I can attest is also not terribly well attended a place for shows Prog bands do either.


  2. Great wrapup! I can attest to The Bedford being the emptiest venue on our (3RDegree’s) 7-date one & only European tour in “15 as well. Jaded Londoners? New York I can attest is also not terribly well attended a place for shows Prog bands do either.


  3. Frank Urbaniak

    Excellent recap Alison. Tickets for King Crimson STARTED at $150 at a nearby venue on their last US tour-crazy. I love the description of Lifesigns-one of my top 5 as well-it is one of those CD’s that is hard to take out of the car for something else-it really grabs me.



Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s