Watson’s Best Prog Albums of 2017: Part 3 — TOP TWENTY # # 10 — 1

Having previously (in the last couple days) shared my 20 “Honorable Mentions” and the first half of my TOP TWENTY ( numbers 20 through 11) I come now to the pay-off.  The following ten albums are, obviously my favorite discs, but also I submit, The Best 10 Progressive Albums of 2017.  Making no apologies for my penchant of melody over rhythm, of consonance over dissonance, I have selected ten works that are heavily laden with beauty and harmony rather than experimentation and edginess (hey! while my friends were listening to the Rolling Stones I was chilling to The Moody Blues)

THE TOP TWENTY:  # # 10 through 1

10)  COMEDY OF ERRORS/House of the Mind


After their great 2015 release SPIRIT, this Glasgow band returns with their crowning achievement.  HOUSE OF THE MIND surpasses their prior releases with a mixture of large-scale symphonic fervor and slower and delicate textured emotionalism. The band is tight and Joe Cairney’s vocals are a real highlight. My favorite tracks are the two longer songs ‘House of the Mind’ and ‘Wandering Jacomus.’  Some of the best new prog is coming from Scotland and Comedy of Errors is perhaps the best of the best.  A+



This is another of my wonderful “finds of the year,” as I had not heard of this band until recently.  My discovery needs to be yours as well as this lush and rich collection of haunting delight will take you to the intersection of classical British pastoral rock, neo folk revival, and chamber prog.  Think of The Enid with the Strawbs sprinkled on top with an undercoating of early Renaissance.  The saxophone work of Ally Carder and the cello of  Jayjay Quick are the perfect garnish to this aural banquet. The last track ‘Stranger in a Strange Land’ is my favorite.

8)  DRIFTING SUN/Twilight


As could be stated for many (if not most) of my picks this year: What stunningly beautiful cover art.  Progressive rock over the decades has been blessed with sight was well as sound.  This British band first caught my ear with their 2015 release TRIP THE LIGHT FANTASTIC, which I very favorably reviewed.  This release maintains that quality of song-writing and delivery. The opening track ‘Twilight’ has some great Gilmourian soaring “axe,” and a nice introduction to this neo-prog album. My favorite tracks are the “Gentle Giant-ish” ‘Soldiers’ and the brilliant 8 minute closer ‘Remain.’ 



This Polish art-rock collective and classical ensemble of prog inspired moody  and elegiac soundscapes should be listed and rated even higher on my list for 2017.  This is a work of art, a true masterpiece…in a year of other stellar releases.  This is spacey, ambient, concerto-like, experimental, drone, but most of all…radiantly bewitching. The 16 minute closer, ‘Solaris’ is my favorite track.  Tell your friends about these Polish purveyors of Prog Perfection!  A+

6)  KAIPA/Children of The Sounds


This is my most joyous and “feel-good” album in this mix of Top Ten. From the “Alice in Wonderland” meets “The Secret Garden” cover art to the delivery of Kaipa’s expected brand of rich and colorful magic-music of Sweden’s mythical past, the disc gives smile after smile as the warmth grows in the listeners chest.  Jonas Reingold’s bass is rich and dark and the perfect counterpoint to Aleena Gibson’s fairy-like soprano.  If you like the Flower Kings you will love this album.  ‘On The Edge of New Horizons’ is one of the best epic-length tracks of the year.

These next “Top Five” albums are all so wonderful that any one of them at the right time could be my favorite. But, for now:

5)  WOBBLER/From Silence to Somewhere


Now that Beardfish is no more, Wobbler has become one of my favorite prog bands from the Continent.  The very thing that causes some critics to be less than fawning (not me: I fawn over these guys), i.e. their use of classic prog “tropes” from Genesis and the other early 70’s legends, is why I find them so delightful and appealing.  There is no piracy or clone-work afoot in their music.  Rather, these Norwegians have given us, in this their fourth album, a robust and loving homage to the spirit and the flavor of the past while still delivering fresh and innovating themes with stellar musicianship.  I love this album and think it should be in your musical collection. This is the genius of Stravinsky sauteed with the catchiness, color, and warmth of Tchaikovsky. The title track alone is magisterial and worth the price of admission.

4)  DISCIPLINE/Captives of the Wine Dark Sea


What do you get when you take the “sound” and “vibe” (sort of, sideways) of Queen, the Beatles, folk-rock, honky-tonk piano runs, and cowbell…and infuse them with one of the greatest vocalists singing in this genre (the protean Matthew Parmenter)?  I give you my favorite album of the y—- er, wait, no….letting the supernal sound of this incredibly great album distract me…sorry.  Did I mention my favorite guitar player, Chris Herin is “dope” on these tracks!!!  His gut-moving playing on tracks 5 & 6 are inspiring and moving. Again, ALL the tracks are my favorite, but who can gainsay the Rock/Jazz fusion running through the final epic song (14:30) ‘Burn The Fire Upon The Rocks.’   A+  Highly and Strongly recommended.

3)  BIG BIG TRAIN/Grimspound


What can I say about BBT that hasn’t been already said (and by my fellow Progarchists, way better)?  This release is sublime and human.  This music roots a listener, who possesses a heart and mind, to the ground of family, home, tradition, and that consciousness of the “democracy of the dead.” For most of the early year this was my numero uno.  Still, # 3 is trinitarian at the least.

2)  BAROCK PROJECT/Detachment


More striking cover art for the eyes. Since the early 70’s, and discovering Goblin, I have had a love affair with Italian popular music–from PFM, Banco del Mutuo Soccorso, and Le Orme, all the way to my favorite soundtrack composer Il Maestro Ennio Morricone.  And now I have a whole new Italian universe of second wave and neo-prog bands to delight my love for a good Rossini styled melody “progged” up to “11.”   Barock Project is the finest Italian  band currently playing this music of the “spheres,” a rapturous Paradiso score for the Ballet at the Empyrean.  For my full review of this album that is ALMOST NUMBER ONE see my review here a Progarchy on October 30th:  Barock Project: DETACHMENT (Album of the Year?)

and now…


1)   RICKARD SJOBLOM’S GUNGFLY/On Her Journey to the Sun


By way of disclaimer: Beardfish (R.I.P.) was one of my favorite bands of the last decade. They were as important to the scene as Marillion, Flower Kings, and Glass Hammer, in my opinion. And as Jeff Lynne was to ELO, Rikard Sjoblom was to Beardfish.  Here he unfolds his compositional skills, his multi-instrumental chops, and his crystal clear (with nary an accent to this Kansas boy’s ears) voice.  For my money, Sjoblom has the best voice in prog (sorry Mr. Longdon).  The best songs are the opening epic ‘Of the Orb’ with its spacious and spacey synth/keys and soaring guitar runs. Also the 12 minute track 10 ‘The River of Sadness’ has such a killer chorus that I’ve been humming it for weeks now. The complex and fusion like instrumental ‘Polymixia’ is also a gem.  ‘He Held an Axe’ is a darker, starker, more heavily rocked story song that really resonates. And, I am convinced that the song ‘Keith (The Son of Sun)’ is a beautiful tribute to Keith Emerson. This is not a perfect album but rather an album that is so near perfect that it has to be Number One.  This masterpiece is what makes progressive music so wonderful.

— Jay

Set Mellotron to 11


7 thoughts on “Watson’s Best Prog Albums of 2017: Part 3 — TOP TWENTY # # 10 — 1

  1. I know music is subjective to personal taste and all that and I will be doing my own list but I can’t believe that nobody has yet put Tiger Moth Tales new album The Depths Of Winter in their lists.
    The album is nothing short of amazing!!

    Liked by 1 person

    1. I agree about the amazing skill and talent of Pete. The first two Tiger Moth Tales releases were brilliant. His latest outing is simply a disc that I have not had the opportunity to hear. This is also why Glass Hammer’s latest record is also absent from my list. Good call, though…I do agree with you! 🙂


    1. Along with TILES, DISCIPLINE, and a couple other what I term “small bands” 3RDegree is my favorite American prog band. I have no doubt you guys will be back riding the top of Watson’s Charts 😀


  2. Mayer More

    Unfortunately we all can not listen to all albums but I was surprised by a bunch of albums that made your top 40 and I gave them only 4 stars out of 5, I have a list of 50 albums I gave 5 stars and a bunch of them are not on your list, I couldn’t rank my list from 1 to 50 but I can say that on your top 10 (1-4,7,8) didn’t make my top 50 (all 4 stars) and that is very interesting to me!
    If I had to pick one album to be # 1 (Very thought) it would be “Amarok – Hunt” that is not even on your top 40 maybe you didn’t even listen to it, 2017 was in my opinion the best year of prog ever! 50 five stars albums in one year is crazy, 2016 was the best till now with 31 five stars, wow! and yes my point of reference is about 500 albums I listened this year! If you wish to have my list of 50 with no particular order I can post it or send it to you! Happy Holidays!



Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s